Skip to content
StockSummarizer
Menu
How to analyze stocks

How to Build a One-Page Competitive Moat Checklist

How to build a one-page competitive moat checklist: switching costs, network effects, cost advantage, intangibles, and scale — scored with evidence and linked to thesis cards. Educational, not advice.

By Published Updated

Stone castle drawbridge and fortified entrance over water at Sirmione
Castello Scaligero drawbridge photograph by Elliott Brown, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and resized.

“Moat” is a loaded word. Used carefully, it means a durable advantage that protects returns — switching costs, network effects, cost advantage, intangible assets, or efficient scale. Used carelessly, it is a slogan. This page is a one-page DIY checklist, not a duplicate of thesis or kill-criteria cards.

Educational only — not financial advice. Scores are subjective literacy tools. Feed results into Bull / Bear / Watch and Thesis → Catalyst → Kill. Sector structure primers (banks, rails, utilities, etc.) supply industry context — link them; do not paste them here.

Direct answer

Write the moat claim in one sentence. For each of five boxes — switching costs, network effects, cost advantage, intangibles, efficient scale — give a 0–5 score and a one-line evidence note from filings or observable customer behaviour. Total is less important than which boxes are empty. Revisit after each major quarter or competitive event. If you cannot evidence a box, score it near zero.

Switching costsHard to leave?Data / workflow lock?Contract term?Score: ___ /5Network effectsMore users →more value?Local or global?Score: ___ /5Cost advantageStructural low cost?Scale? Access?Durable vs fad?Score: ___ /5Intangibles / scaleBrand, IP, license?Regulated scarcity?Distribution scale?Score: ___ /5
Score lightly (0–5) and force a one-line evidence note per box. This is a moat checklist — not a substitute for thesis, catalyst, and kill cards.
Pick the claimWhat moat ismanagement selling?Evidence testFiling / customerbehaviour proofScore 0–5With one-lineevidence eachLink thesis cardsBull / bear / watch+ kill criteriaRevisit quarterlyMoats erode —log changes
Do not invent a fifth decision card. Use this checklist to feed evidence into Bull/Bear/Watch and thesis→catalyst→kill.

Evidence habits (not vibes)

Moat boxStronger evidenceWeaker evidence
Switching costsRetention, multi-year contracts, data portability frictionMarketing claim of “sticky customers”
Network effectsLiquidity / density metrics; two-sided growth“Platform” label alone
Cost advantageUnit costs vs peers over cycleTemporary discounting
IntangiblesPatents, licences, brand pricing power with dataLogo recognition anecdotes
Efficient scaleNatural monopoly / regulated utility traits“We’re the biggest” without barriers

Hypothetical one-pager fill

BoxScore (hyp.)Evidence note (hyp.)
Switching costs4Multi-year SaaS + switching cost cited in AIF
Network effects1Single-player tool; no density metric
Cost advantage2Scale helps opex; peers catching up
Intangibles3Niche IP; limited brand pricing proof
Efficient scale0Competitive market; low barriers
ActionWatchMoat is narrow — valuation & execution matter more
FieldYour notes
Moat claim (1 sentence)
Strongest box + evidence
Empty boxes
Link to bull case
Link to kill criteria
Next review date

Sources

  • Classic strategy / investing literature on economic moats (e.g., structural sources of advantage: switching costs, network effects, cost, intangibles, scale) — use as a vocabulary lens, not as issuer-specific proof.
  • Issuer-specific proof still comes from continuous disclosure under NI 51-102 (AIF, MD&A, financials) and observable operating metrics.

Media credits

  • Hero: “Sirmione - Castello Scaligero - drawbridge (4890047349).jpg” by Elliott Brown, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and resized to 1280x720. Real photograph, not AI-generated.

By Andrew · stocksummarizer.com

Guides · coming soon

Want the playbook in one place?

We are compiling free literacy hubs into paid ebook playbooks (Research, Valuation without fake precision, Dividend safety). Soft launch only for now — keep using these free guides, and browse ebooks when a guide ships.

Preview ebook shelf

Educational only — not financial advice. Do your own research. See our disclosures.