Skip to content
StockSummarizer
Menu
Valuation & multiples

P/B vs Peers: A Canada-First Comparison Guide

How to compare price-to-book across non-bank TSX peers: align book value basis, goodwill and accounting policies, handle IFRS 17 insurers, and read P/B against ROE. Educational.

By Published Updated

A freight train of covered autorack cars on tracks beside warehouses in Brampton, Ontario
Freight train in Brampton, Ontario photograph by Milan Suvajac, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and resized.

Comparing P/B across companies only works if their book values are built the same way. Two industrials can own similar plants yet report very different book values because one bought its assets recently, one made big acquisitions, or one revalues property. And P/B gaps mean little until you line them up against ROE.

Peer selection basics (same business model, median not mean) are in P/E vs peers: a Canada-first comparison guide and how to use peer tables without cherry-picking comps. For banks, use valuation for banks: P/B, ROE, and why P/E alone fails. This post covers non-bank asset-heavy peers: insurers, industrials, materials and holding companies. It is educational; figures are hypothetical.

Direct answer

Pick peers with the same business model and similar asset intensity. Align book value: same equity basis (attributable, preferreds removed), same treatment of goodwill, same accounting policies for property, and for insurers, the same IFRS 17 view (book with or without CSM). Then compare P/B against ROE, not P/B alone. A stock with a lower P/B than peers at a similar ROE deserves a closer look; one with a lower P/B and lower ROE may be priced correctly.

0x1x2x3x0%4%8%12%16%Return on equity (%)Price-to-book (x)YouABCDE
Hypothetical: four peers line up with higher P/B for higher ROE. Peer E sits above the line (premium, perhaps less goodwill or a better franchise). Your company sits below it: a 12% ROE at only 1.1x book.

Book value alignment rules

RuleWhy it matters
Same equity basisAttributable to shareholders, preferreds and hybrids removed for all
Show goodwill as a % of bookAcquirers carry more book that may not earn its keep
Note cost vs fair value policiesIAS 16 revaluation and IAS 40 fair value raise book versus cost-model peers
Same dateBook values from different quarter ends drift
Same currency at closing ratesConvert USD reporters at the balance-sheet date
IFRS 17 insurers on the same viewBook alone or book plus after-tax CSM, for every insurer
US GAAP peers flaggedUS insurers report under different long-duration rules; book is not directly comparable
Use mid-cycle ROE for cyclicalsPeak ROE flatters; trough ROE punishes

Peer P/B table (hypothetical)

CompanyP/BROE (3-yr avg)P/B ÷ ROEGoodwill % of bookPolicy note
Your company1.10x12%0.09210%Cost model
Peer A1.00x8%0.12515%Cost model
Peer B1.40x11%0.12720%Cost model
Peer C1.80x14%0.12925%Cost model
Peer D0.70x5%0.14035%Cost model
Peer E2.60x13%0.2005%Revalues some property
Peer median1.40x11%0.129

On P/B alone, your company is 21% below the peer median (1.10 vs 1.40). Against ROE, the gap is wider: at the median 0.129 per point of ROE, a 12% ROE implies about 1.5x. Before calling that a bargain, ask why: smaller size, a weaker balance sheet, a cyclical ROE that looks better than it will be, or a lower-quality asset base.

Peer A0.125Peer B0.127Peer C0.129Peer D0.140Peer E0.200Your company0.092
Hypothetical: dividing P/B by ROE gives a rough 'price per point of return'. The peer median is about 0.129; applied to your company's 12% ROE it implies about 1.5x book versus 1.1x today. A crude cross-check, not a target.

Canada-first issues for P/B peer sets

IssueWhat to do
Few TSX peers in a nicheAdd US or global peers, flagged; see how to compare a TSX stock to its US peer fairly
Life insurers under IFRS 17Compare book plus after-tax CSM for all, and see how to analyze insurers differently from banks
Holding companiesCompare discount to NAV, not P/B, when holdings are at cost or equity method
Resource issuersP/B depends on impairment history; pair with price/NAV
REITsBook is close to NAV under IAS 40; see valuing REITs

Checklist

StepDone when
Peers chosenSame business model and asset intensity
Book alignedBasis, date, currency, goodwill and policies noted
ROE addedMid-cycle or 3-year average
Median usedNot the mean
P/B vs ROE checkedScatter or P/B ÷ ROE ratio
Gap explainedSize, leverage, cyclicality, asset quality
Conclusion writtenDiscount or premium, and whether it looks justified

Go deeper

A good screener or broker research tool can pull P/B and ROE for a peer set quickly; compare options in how to compare Canadian discount brokers and set up filters with screener filters that match your process. Then run the result through how to use P/B in a simple valuation checklist.

Sources

  • IAS 16 Property, Plant and Equipment (cost and revaluation models); IAS 40 Investment Property.
  • IFRS 3 Business Combinations (goodwill); IFRS 17 Insurance Contracts.
  • IAS 21 The Effects of Changes in Foreign Exchange Rates.

Media credits

  • Hero: “Brampton ON Freight-Train 2022-07-05 (5).jpg” by Milan Suvajac, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and resized to 1280x720. Real photograph of a freight train in Brampton, Ontario, not AI-generated.

By Andrew · stocksummarizer.com

Affiliate · disclosed

Brokers and tools for DIY stock research

When we mention discount brokers, screeners, or charting platforms, we may earn a commission from disclosed partners. That never changes what we cover — clarity first. Soft ebook guides are coming; free literacy stays free.

See disclosed partners

Guides · coming soon

Want the playbook in one place?

We are compiling free literacy hubs into paid ebook playbooks (Research, Valuation without fake precision, Dividend safety). Soft launch only for now — keep using these free guides, and browse ebooks when a guide ships.

Preview ebook shelf

Educational only — not financial advice. Do your own research. See our disclosures.