Skip to content
StockSummarizer
Menu
How to analyze stocks

How to Use Peer Tables Without Cherry-Picking Comps

How to use peer tables without cherry-picking comps: write screen rules first, align definitions, keep inconvenient peers, and show median plus range. Educational, not advice.

By Published Updated

Open historical account book ledger with handwritten entries
Account book ledger image by John Carlin, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons / The Met. Cropped and resized.

Peer tables are powerful — and easy to rig. Cherry-picking comps that make your target look cheap is not relative valuation; it is advocacy. This page is how to build peer sets with rules you could defend to a sceptical friend.

Educational only — not financial advice. Scatter points are hypothetical. Pair with compare two TSX peers, triangulating multiples, and when P/E misleads.

Direct answer

Write the investment question first. Define peer-screen rules (size, model, geography, cycle) before listing tickers. Build the table on aligned periods and definitions. Keep inconvenient comps and explain structural differences. Show median and range, not only the flattering average. If you exclude a name, cite the rule.

State the questionValuation? Ops?Credit?Define peer screenRules beforenamesApply screenSize, model,geography, cycleBuild tableSame defs /same dateExplain outliersDon't deleteinconvenient comps
Write the screen rules first. Naming favourite comps first is how bias enters.
Screen rulesMarket-cap bandBusiness modelGeography mixCycle exposureMetric hygieneSame FY/LTMIFRS vs non-GAAPFX / unitsOne-times strippedFairness checksInclude tough compsShow median + rangeNote structural diffsLink sector primerAbuse patternsDropping cheap peersMixing bank & retailerPeak vs trough yearsStory-only peers
If a peer is excluded, write the rule that excludes it — not a vibe.
Story zone05101520510152025Hyp. P/EHyp. growth %Peer APeer BPeer CTargetStory peer
Outliers need explanation. Deleting the awkward peer is not analysis.

Minimum peer-table hygiene

Hygiene itemPassFail
Screen written firstRules in notes“These are the comps management uses” alone
Period alignmentSame LTM / FYMix of stale years
Metric definitionIFRS or labelled non-GAAPEBITDA soup
Exclusions loggedRule citedSilent deletions
ContextSector primer linkedPure multiple shopping

Sources

  • Relative valuation practice: peer sets should match economics, not tickers of convenience (literacy framing).
  • National Instrument 52-112 (when peer tables use non-GAAP metrics — label and define).
  • IFRS comparability concepts via consistent accounting policies across the set (qualitative).

Media credits

  • Hero: “Account Book Ledger MET DP214206.jpg” by John Carlin, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons (Metropolitan Museum of Art open access). Cropped and resized to 1280x720. Real historical photograph/object image, not AI-generated.

By Andrew · stocksummarizer.com

Guides · coming soon

Want the playbook in one place?

We are compiling free literacy hubs into paid ebook playbooks (Research, Valuation without fake precision, Dividend safety). Soft launch only for now — keep using these free guides, and browse ebooks when a guide ships.

Preview ebook shelf

Educational only — not financial advice. Do your own research. See our disclosures.