Skip to content
StockSummarizer
Menu
Valuation & multiples

When P/E Misleads on TSX Stocks

Seven situations where the price-to-earnings ratio misleads Canadian DIY investors — cyclicals, USD reporters, REITs, insurers, heavy depreciation, one-offs and holding companies — and which metric to use instead. Educational, not advice.

By Published Updated

The Nutrien Lanigan potash mine in Saskatchewan at sunset, with steam plumes rising over the prairie and an old wooden shed in the foreground
Nutrien Lanigan potash mine, Saskatchewan, October 2025. Photo by Quintin Soloviev, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and resized.

The price-to-earnings ratio is the most quoted valuation number in investing, and on the TSX it misleads more often than people expect. Canada’s market is heavy in cyclicals (energy, materials), asset-heavy infrastructure (pipelines, telecom, railways), fair-value accounting (REITs, insurers) and companies that report in US dollars. Each of these bends P/E in a predictable way.

If you’re new to the ratio, start with what P/E means for Canadian DIY investors. Educational only — not financial advice. Figures are hypothetical.

Direct answer

P/E misleads when earnings aren’t a stable, cash-backed measure of what the business normally earns. On the TSX that usually means: commodity producers at the top or bottom of the cycle, companies reporting in USD while trading in CAD, REITs and insurers with fair-value or IFRS 17 effects, capital-heavy businesses where depreciation differs from real maintenance spending, quarters with big one-offs, and holding companies. In those cases, switch to mid-cycle multiples, EV/EBITDA, P/FCF, P/B or P/AFFO.

The seven situations at a glance

#SituationWhy P/E misleadsUse instead
1Cyclical at peak or troughEarnings are temporarily high or lowMid-cycle P/E, EV/EBITDA at mid-cycle prices, P/NAV
2USD reporter, CAD priceCurrency mismatch inside the ratioConvert one side; compare like with like
3REITsFair-value gains and losses swing net incomeP/AFFO and P/NAV
4InsurersIFRS 17 and investment-mark volatilityP/B with ROE, core/operating EPS
5Heavy depreciationD&A ≠ maintenance capexEV/EBITDA, P/FCF
6One-offs (impairments, gains)Reported EPS isn’t recurringNormalized EPS — reconcile it yourself
7Holding companiesEarnings mix of owned stakes, marks, feesSum-of-the-parts, discount to NAV

1. Cyclicals: low P/E at the top, high P/E at the bottom

For oil and gas producers, miners, fertilizer and forestry companies, earnings follow commodity prices. When prices are high, earnings are high and the P/E looks low — just when the risk of a downturn is highest. At the bottom, earnings collapse and the P/E looks absurdly high, often near the best entry point.

0×10×20×30×40×30×Year 1trough12×Year 2recovery5×Year 3peak8×Year 4fading25×Year 5trough
Hypothetical producer with a constant $30 share price. Trailing P/E is lowest at the earnings peak and highest at the trough — the opposite of what a "cheap vs expensive" reading suggests.
Year (hypothetical)EPSP/E at $30Mid-cycle EPSP/E on mid-cycle
1 (trough)$1.0030×$2.5012×
3 (peak)$6.005×$2.5012×

Using a mid-cycle EPS (an average over a full cycle, or EPS at a long-run commodity price) gives a steady 12× — a more useful starting point. Our oil & gas producers, base metals and gold sector pages show how cyclical multiples swing.

2. Currency mismatch

Plenty of TSX-listed companies report in US dollars. Data sites usually handle the conversion, but not always — and if you compute P/E yourself from the financial statements, you must convert. A CAD price divided by USD EPS overstates the P/E by the exchange rate.

HypotheticalValue
TSX priceC$54.00
EPS (reported in USD)US$3.00
Naive P/E (mixed currencies)18.0×
USD/CAD rate (hypothetical)1.35
EPS in CADC$4.05
Correct P/E13.3×

3. REITs

Fair-value changes on investment properties run through IFRS net income, so a REIT’s “EPS” can swing wildly without any change in rent. Use FFO/AFFO-based multiples and NAV — see valuing REITs and the REIT sector page.

4. Insurers

Since IFRS 17 took effect in 2023, insurer earnings are presented differently, and investment-market movements can still create noise. Many Canadian insurers also publish “core” or “underlying” earnings (non-GAAP). Compare P/B with sustainable ROE as you would for a bank (bank valuation), and see the insurers sector page.

5. Depreciation that doesn’t match reality

Pipelines, telecoms, railways and utilities book large depreciation charges. If depreciation is higher than the true maintenance spending (common for long-lived assets), earnings understate cash generation and P/E looks expensive. If it’s lower (assets that need constant reinvestment, such as some telecom networks), P/E flatters. Compare D&A with sustaining capex in the cash-flow statement, then use free cash flow or EV/EBITDA. See the midstream and telecom pages.

6. One-offs

Impairments, asset-sale gains, restructuring charges, tax-rate changes, legal settlements and mark-to-market moves can dominate a single year. Use normalized earnings — but build the normalization yourself from the reconciliation, because management’s “adjusted EPS” tends to remove only bad items. Reading non-GAAP metrics critically covers this.

7. Holding companies

Conglomerates and holding companies own stakes in other businesses, sometimes marked to market and sometimes equity-accounted. Consolidated EPS mixes all of it. A sum-of-the-parts valuation compared with the market cap (the “holdco discount”) is usually more informative than P/E.

A quick decision tree

Commodity-driven?Use mid-cyclemultiples or NAVFair-valueaccounting?REIT: P/AFFOInsurer: P/BHeavyD&A?Use EV/EBITDAor P/FCFBig one-offs?Normalize EPSyourselfCurrencymismatch?Convert beforedividingNone of theseP/E is a fairstarting point
Ask these questions in order; the first "yes" usually tells you which metric to lean on.

When P/E is fine

P/E works reasonably well for stable, profitable businesses whose earnings track cash: many grocers and consumer staples, waste and services companies, and banks as one input alongside P/B. Even then, compare it with the company’s own history and peers, and cross-check with a DCF — see triangulating multiples, DCF and peer checks.

Go deeper

A “which multiple?” cheat sheet by TSX sector is planned for the Valuation Without Fake Precision ebook. The rules above are the free version.

Media credits

  • Hero: “Nutrien Lanigan Potash.jpg” by Quintin Soloviev, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and resized to 1280×720. Real photograph, not AI-generated.

By Andrew · stocksummarizer.com

Guides · coming soon

Want the playbook in one place?

We are compiling free literacy hubs into paid ebook playbooks (Research, Valuation without fake precision, Dividend safety). Soft launch only for now — keep using these free guides, and browse ebooks when a guide ships.

Preview ebook shelf

Educational only — not financial advice. Do your own research. See our disclosures.