Skip to content
StockSummarizer
Menu
Valuation & multiples

How to Use Earnings Yield in a Simple Valuation Checklist

A one-page earnings-yield checklist for TSX stocks: an eligibility gate, normalized EPS, a fair yield from required return, growth and ROE, and a price range. Educational.

By Published Updated

The NAV CANADA air traffic control tower in Quebec City against a clear blue sky
NAV CANADA control tower in Quebec City photograph by Wilfredor, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and resized.

This is the one-page earnings-yield checklist. It assumes you know what earnings yield means, can calculate it in CAD, know when it misleads and have a peer comparison. The P/E version of this checklist picks low, mid and high multiples from history and peers; see how to use P/E in a simple valuation checklist. This one works from the other direction: it asks what earnings yield the business should earn given your required return, its growth and how much it must reinvest to get that growth. It is educational; all figures are hypothetical.

Direct answer

Pass an eligibility gate (positive, reasonably stable, normalized EPS). Then set a fair earnings yield = (r − g) ÷ (1 − g ÷ ROE), where r is your required return, g is long-run earnings growth and ROE is the return on the equity the company reinvests. Fair price = normalized EPS ÷ fair yield. Run bear, base and bull cases, compare with today’s price and cross-check with EBIT ÷ EV and FCF yield. The formula’s main lesson: growth only adds value when it earns more than the required return.

GatePositive, stableEPS?NormalizeMid-cycle EPS,one-offs outFair yield(r − g) ÷(1 − g ÷ ROE)PriceNormalized EPS÷ fair yieldCross-checkEBIT ÷ EV,FCF yield
Five steps from "is earnings yield the right tool?" to a price range.

The earnings-yield checklist

#StepQuestionPass if
1EligibilityPositive EPS in most years; not a bank, insurer or REIT?Yes
2NormalizeMid-cycle or three-to-five-year average, one-offs removed?Not a peak or trough year
3BasisReported diluted EPS in CAD (adjusted only as a labelled line)?Built per the calculation post
4GrowthLong-run growth the business can sustain?Below nominal economic growth over the long run, or explained
5ReinvestmentROE on new investment estimated?Supported by history, not hope
6Fair yield(r − g) ÷ (1 − g ÷ ROE), bear / base / bullWithin the peer range, or explained
7Price rangeNormalized EPS ÷ fair yieldCalculated
8Leverage checkAfter-tax EBIT ÷ EV close to the earnings yield?Gap explained
9Cash checkFCF yield and earnings yield tell the same story?No big contradiction

Why the formula has ROE in it

A company that grows by reinvesting must retain part of its earnings. If it reinvests at an ROE of 15% and grows 4%, it needs to retain 4% ÷ 15% ≈ 27% of earnings; the other 73% is available to shareholders. A fair yield is the yield that, combined with growth, delivers your required return. If ROE on new investment equals your required return, growth adds nothing and the fair earnings yield simply equals r.

Hypothetical, r = 9%Growth 3%Growth 5%
ROE 9% (equals r)9.0%9.0%
ROE 12%8.0%6.9%
ROE 18%7.2%5.5%

Read across: faster growth lowers the fair yield (raises the fair P/E) only when ROE is above the required return. This is why a low earnings yield on a low-return business is a warning sign.

Turning it into a price range (hypothetical)

Normalized diluted EPS: $3.00. Share price today: $42.00 (earnings yield 7.1%, P/E 14.0x).

ScenarioRequired return (r)Growth (g)ROEFair earnings yieldFair P/EFair price
Bear9.0%3.0%12%8.0%12.5x$37.50
Base8.5%4.0%15%6.1%16.3x$48.89
Bull8.0%5.0%18%4.2%24.1x$72.22
$0$20$40$60$80$37.50Bear$48.89Base$72.22BullFair price per share
Hypothetical fair price per share in three scenarios. Today's $42 sits between the bear and base cases. The bull case relies on a narrow gap between r and g and should not be the anchor.

The range is wide because small changes in r − g move the answer a lot. Narrow it by checking the base case against the peer median earnings yield and against the company’s own history. The same constant-growth logic, with more stages and explicit cash flows, is in how to build a simple DCF without fake precision.

Using a bond yield as a sanity check

A government bond yield you look up yourself can anchor r: required return ≈ a risk-free yield plus an equity risk premium. Two cautions. First, the premium is an assumption, not a market quote; write down the one you use. Second, if your r moves every time bond yields move, your fair price will too. Many DIY investors keep r fixed in a range (for example 8–10% in these hypothetical cases) and treat rate moves as a reason to revisit, not to recalculate daily.

Red flags that override the checklist

Red flagWhy it overrides
EPS well above operating cash flow for several yearsEarnings quality is low; see how to read cash flow from operations vs net income
Growth comes from acquisitions funded with sharesPer-share growth is lower than reported growth
ROE propped up by high leverageFair yield understates risk
Fair yield below about half of rThe answer is mostly the growth assumption
Large gap between earnings yield and after-tax EBIT ÷ EVLeverage is doing the work; see the peer post

Go deeper

Combine this range with P/E, P/FCF and a DCF in triangulating multiples, DCF and peer checks. To compare the result with what the business returns on capital, see what ROE is.

Sources

  • Gordon, M. J. (1959). “Dividends, Earnings, and Stock Prices.” Review of Economics and Statistics (constant-growth model).
  • Koller, T., Goedhart, M. and Wessels, D. Valuation: Measuring and Managing the Value of Companies (McKinsey & Company), the value driver formula.
  • IAS 33 Earnings per Share.

Media credits

  • Hero: “NAV CANADA air traffic control tower in Quebec City.jpg” by Wilfredor, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons. Cropped and resized to 1280x720. Real photograph of the NAV CANADA control tower in Quebec City, not AI-generated.

By Andrew · stocksummarizer.com

Guides · coming soon

Want the playbook in one place?

We are compiling free literacy hubs into paid ebook playbooks (Research, Valuation without fake precision, Dividend safety). Soft launch only for now — keep using these free guides, and browse ebooks when a guide ships.

Preview ebook shelf

Educational only — not financial advice. Do your own research. See our disclosures.